The Beast
Rating? No grazie!
Sempre su CIT
NEW YORK (Dow Jones)--CIT Group's (CIT) failure to secure government support sent investors scurrying for cover, as some prominent analysts called on them to brace for a bankruptcy.
A bondholder call is currently being held with restructuring firm Houlihan Lokey, according to two CIT bondholders. The purpose of the call is to discuss options and possibly form a bondholders' committee, although the two bondholders said no such committee has been formed yet.
The same bondholders said a possible debt exchange could involve trading in unsecured near-term bond maturities for secured debt using unencumbered assets, as well as extending the maturity of the debt.
According to a report in The Wall Street Journal, CIT has given its bondholders 24 hours to come up with $2 billion in rescue financing, saying without help it will likely file for bankruptcy protection from creditors. Even that figure, however, could prove insufficient.
"We believe the figure is in the range of $4 to $6 billion+ making outside capital sources shy away from such a heavy recapitalization," wrote research firm CreditSights in a note early Thursday morning. "We believe the prudent course for bondholders is to brace for bankruptcy."
As Bank of America Merrill Lynch put it in a recent note, CIT, with only 1% of the U.S. lending market, is clearly not too big to fail in the government's eyes - which gives it fewer options. Fitch Ratings on Thursday downgraded its rating on CIT and its subsidiaries to C from BB-, indicating that "default of some kind appears imminent or inevitable."
CIT bond prices fell sharply Thursday, with its 7.625% notes due November 2012 down 22.25 points to 45 cents on the dollar in heavy trade, according to MarketAxess, while its August 2009 floating notes are down 8.25 points at 56 cents.
Recovery for CIT senior unsecured bonds in event of bankruptcy would likely be in the low 50s, with a spread between 40-55 cants on the dollar, estimated Jeff Meli at Barclays Capital in a conference call Thursday morning.
The cost of protecting $10 million of CIT's senior bonds against default for five years jumped to 48 points up front Thursday, according to Phoenix Partners Group - which roughly equals the highest costs seen Monday. This means it costs investors $4.8 million up front plus a $500,000 annual fee to insure this debt. That's compared with 34 points up front Wednesday before trade in CIT stock was halted.
The impact of a potential credit event in CIT's credit default swaps would be half of the impact of the Lehman bankruptcy filing, Meli said. Net notional CDS on CIT is $3.5 billion, about half the amount on Lehman. With a 50% anticipated recovery, the total loss to CIT CDS protection sellers would be $1.75 billion.
CIT's lending business doesn't present the systemic risk associated with Lehman's commercial paper business, said Fordham University finance professor John Hunter.
"I don't see where this really had any dire consequences," Hunter said. "That's why the market is brushing it off."
Hunter added that the government did the right thing in rebuffing CIT. "It's going to be bad for the company involved, but good for competitors and the market as a whole," he said. "It's putting moral hazard back in place."
Bond investors won't be the only ones feeling the pinch. Dividends on three outstanding CIT non-cumulative preferred stocks are likely to be suspended, said Bank of America Merrill Lynch analysts in a note.
They cost $183 million annually, and CIT had been issuing common equity to maintain these payments over the past few quarters. A distressed debt exchange would likely result in the suspension of dividends until certain financial benchmarks are met.
CIT shares were down 68% at 52 cents in recent trade.
NEW YORK (Dow Jones)--CIT Group's (CIT) failure to secure government support sent investors scurrying for cover, as some prominent analysts called on them to brace for a bankruptcy.
A bondholder call is currently being held with restructuring firm Houlihan Lokey, according to two CIT bondholders. The purpose of the call is to discuss options and possibly form a bondholders' committee, although the two bondholders said no such committee has been formed yet.
The same bondholders said a possible debt exchange could involve trading in unsecured near-term bond maturities for secured debt using unencumbered assets, as well as extending the maturity of the debt.
According to a report in The Wall Street Journal, CIT has given its bondholders 24 hours to come up with $2 billion in rescue financing, saying without help it will likely file for bankruptcy protection from creditors. Even that figure, however, could prove insufficient.
"We believe the figure is in the range of $4 to $6 billion+ making outside capital sources shy away from such a heavy recapitalization," wrote research firm CreditSights in a note early Thursday morning. "We believe the prudent course for bondholders is to brace for bankruptcy."
As Bank of America Merrill Lynch put it in a recent note, CIT, with only 1% of the U.S. lending market, is clearly not too big to fail in the government's eyes - which gives it fewer options. Fitch Ratings on Thursday downgraded its rating on CIT and its subsidiaries to C from BB-, indicating that "default of some kind appears imminent or inevitable."
CIT bond prices fell sharply Thursday, with its 7.625% notes due November 2012 down 22.25 points to 45 cents on the dollar in heavy trade, according to MarketAxess, while its August 2009 floating notes are down 8.25 points at 56 cents.
Recovery for CIT senior unsecured bonds in event of bankruptcy would likely be in the low 50s, with a spread between 40-55 cants on the dollar, estimated Jeff Meli at Barclays Capital in a conference call Thursday morning.
The cost of protecting $10 million of CIT's senior bonds against default for five years jumped to 48 points up front Thursday, according to Phoenix Partners Group - which roughly equals the highest costs seen Monday. This means it costs investors $4.8 million up front plus a $500,000 annual fee to insure this debt. That's compared with 34 points up front Wednesday before trade in CIT stock was halted.
The impact of a potential credit event in CIT's credit default swaps would be half of the impact of the Lehman bankruptcy filing, Meli said. Net notional CDS on CIT is $3.5 billion, about half the amount on Lehman. With a 50% anticipated recovery, the total loss to CIT CDS protection sellers would be $1.75 billion.
CIT's lending business doesn't present the systemic risk associated with Lehman's commercial paper business, said Fordham University finance professor John Hunter.
"I don't see where this really had any dire consequences," Hunter said. "That's why the market is brushing it off."
Hunter added that the government did the right thing in rebuffing CIT. "It's going to be bad for the company involved, but good for competitors and the market as a whole," he said. "It's putting moral hazard back in place."
Bond investors won't be the only ones feeling the pinch. Dividends on three outstanding CIT non-cumulative preferred stocks are likely to be suspended, said Bank of America Merrill Lynch analysts in a note.
They cost $183 million annually, and CIT had been issuing common equity to maintain these payments over the past few quarters. A distressed debt exchange would likely result in the suspension of dividends until certain financial benchmarks are met.
CIT shares were down 68% at 52 cents in recent trade.